Schalick puts together strong second half to take a Halloween thriller from Pennsville in their South Jersey Group I playoff opener
SOUTH JERSEY GROUP I
Quarterfinals
Glassboro 41, Audubon 0
Salem at KIPP, Saturday
Schalick 21, Pennsville 16
Woodbury at Paulsboro, Saturday
Semifinals
Salem-KIPP winner at Glassboro
Schalick vs. Woodbury-Paulsboro winner
Finals
Nov. 14 at highest seed
By Al Muskewitz
Riverview Sports News
PENNSVILLE – It’s nights like this that Kevin Leamy was thinking about when he was approved as Schalick’s new football coach way back in March.
Even when the Cougars bogged down with a four-game losing streak in the middle of the season the first-time head coach was confident if they could get it turned around and play their best ball when it counted most they could do something special.
They delivered on that Friday, putting together a big second half defensively and making big plays offensively to knock off third-seeded Pennsville 21-16 in the opening round of the South Jersey Group I playoffs.
“I knew coming into the season that we were going to struggle early because there are a lot of new things … so there was going to be an adjustment period,” Leamy said. “But the message from that very first time I saw them was if you keep improving and we’re playing our best football when we need to, we can make some noise. And that’s what these kids are doing.
“They did exactly what I wanted them to do; they should be really proud of themselves. Hats off to them for coming out and playing the way they needed to in the second half.”
The sixth-seeded Cougars (4-6) now await the winner of Saturday’s Woodbury -Paulsboro game to determine their second-round plans. If second-seeded Paulsboro wins, the Cougars will be there next Saturday. If Woodbury pulls the upset, the Cougars will host Friday.
The night didn’t start off well for them. Pennsville, hosting its first playoff game since 2016, put together two time-consuming 80-play drives to take a 16-7 halftime lead.
The Eagles did it all on the ground; they didn’t throw a pass in the first half. They rushed for 165 yards in the first two quarters and Rylan Hardy had 133 of it.
”They were really running all over us,” defensive back David Stewart said.
But the break gave the Cougars a chance to make some adjustments and they came out a different team in the second half. They held their hosts to just 22 yards rushing, 53 yards total and two first downs in the second half.
“We dared them to do whatever they wanted because we were going to come at them any way we could,” linebacker Dezyon Purnell said.
“It’s hard to make adjustments on the fly,” Leamy said. “We knew we just had to get to halftime and if we could get there we could make the adjustment we need to and then shut the run down in the second half. We knew if we could stop them, we had enough offensive firepower to win the game.”
The Cougars showed that firepower midway through the third quarter when Kenny Bartee hit Stewart with a 54-yard bomb on third-and-15 to get within 16-14 with 7:20 left in it. Stewart put them ahead in the final minute when he fell on a loose ball in the end zone after Bartee fumbled inches from the goal line after a 9-yard gain.
“My guts dropped completely,” Bartee said describing his reaction to the fumble. “I tried to lean the ball over and he just punched it out; it was a great play by the kid. I give my thanks to David Stewart. He came in the clutch and got it back for me.”
“I just thought I had to get there as quick as I could,” Stewart said. “It was moving around a little bit and I just grabbed it as hard as I could and laid on it. I was nervous. I really thought they were going to get on the ball and capitalize on it, but I just made a play on it.”
The teams battled through an intense but scoreless fourth quarter.
Not to be overlooked in the loss was the play of Pennsville backup quarterback Jake Layfield. The junior was pressed into action on the opening possession when four-year starter Robbie McDade sustained a foot injury on a pass Dylan Sheehan tipped, picked and returned for a touchdown but later overturned by penalty and played the rest of the game.
Like a batter stepping in for another hitter mid-count, Layfield completed the Eagles’ opening drive, burrowing in from the 1 for his first career touchdown. He then flawlessly directed the Eagles on his own 12-play, 80-yard drive with Hardy scoring on a 12-yard run. Eagles coach Mike Healy said he “cannot be more impressed” with the job his quarterback of the future did.
“You always have to imagine the possibility,” Layfield said. “When you’re the next man up you have to know there’s always a situation where you’re going to go in, whether you’re second, third, fourth. They were big shoes to fill. I don’t think I filled them up enough ultimately and it led us to fall short.
“I started in a little better than I finished. I started with good field position and drove down and scored; that got me fired up. Halftime kind of cooled me off a little bit. It would’ve been better if there was no halftime, to be honest.”
The Eagles started their last possession near midfield with 6:08 to play. As much as McDade wanted to get back in the game, Healy said it “wasn’t in the books” for the 3,000-yard passer to return for a potential heroic finish, so the comeback rested with Layfield.
They got it moving, but another ill-timed penalty threw them back. Ayden Jenkins ran down Layfield for a loss on third down and then Stewart knocked away a deep fourth-down pass to Hayden Sherman.
“We made mistakes in the second half that set us being the sticks and behind where we wanted to be,” Healy said. “But the bottom line is they made the big plays tonight and we didn’t. We knew they were a good team going in and they executed better tonight.”
After the fourth-down pass fell incomplete, the Cougars took over and ran out the final three minutes plus to keep their season alive.
“it was a hell of a win,” Purnell said. “I’m glad we got this for our team, glad we got this for the Cougars, glad we got this for our coach.”
“We’re getting hot at the right time, all our pieces are falling into place at the exact right time,” added Jenkins. “This is where it all comes together and I think we’re going to go and beat whoever we play next week and play even better.”

(Photo by Amory Alleyne)
Schalick 21, Pennsville 16
| SCH | PV | |
| 14 | 1st Downs | 14 |
| 30-136 | Rushing | 37-187 |
| 8-14-0 | Passing | 2-4-0 |
| 147 | Passing yds. | 31 |
| 0-0 | Fumbles-lost | 1-1 |
| 1-19.0 | Punts-avg | 1-23.0 |
| 3-25 | Penalties | 5-45 |
| Schalick | 7 | 0 | 14 | 0- | 21 |
| Pennsville | 8 | 8 | 0 | 0- | 16 |
SCORING SUMMARY
P – Jake Layfield 1 run (Adrian Alleyne run), 4:18 1Q
S – Kenny Bartee 7 run (Hunter Dragotta kick), 0:03 1Q
P – Rylan Hardy 12 run (Perry Meranti pass from Jake Layfield), 6:35 2Q
S – David Stewart 54 pass from Kenny Bartee (Hunter Dragotta kick), 7:20 3Q
S – David Stewart fumble recovery in end zone (Hunter Dragotta kick) 0:27 3Q
GROUP I PLAYOFFS
NORTH I
Butler 42, Hawthorne 7
New Milford 35, Bogota 21
Kittatinny at Wallkill Valley, Saturday
Kinnelon 26, Park Ridge 7
NORTH II
Mountain Lakes 42, Brearley 0
Cedar Grove 35, Glen Ridge 20
Secaucus at New Providence, Saturday
Hasbrouck Heights 45, Wood-Ridge 14
SOUTH
Glassboro 41, Audubon 0
Salem at KIPP, Saturday
Schalick 21, Pennsville 16
Woodbury at Paulsboro, Saturday
CENTRAL
Burlington City 49, Bound Brook 0
Manville 35, Asbury Park 0
Pt. Pleasant Beach at Riverside, Saturday
Shore 34, New Egypt 0
