First loss, last loss

Collingswood hands Schalick field hockey first loss of the season in the South Jersey Group I quarterfinals

SJ GROUP I PLAYOFFS
Wednesday’s Quarterfinals
Shore 11, Salem 0
Haddon Heights 4, Gloucester 0
West Deptford 9, Bordentown 0
Collingswood 3, Schalick 1

By Al Muskewitz
Riverview Sports News

PITTSGROVE – Among the keys to Schalick’s unprecedented field hockey success this season were a high-powered offense and a penchant for doing all the little things.

But both were missing Wednesday and the Cougars suffered their first loss of the season, 3-1 to 10th-seeded Collingswood in the South Jersey Group I quarterfinals.

“It was a tough one,” Schalick coach Heather Cheesman said. “I just think we didn’t do the little things. We were sloppy, not getting by, getting lots of cards, just little details. The little things hurt us.

“They weren’t doing them well, either, but they did them better than us. … They did what they had to do today to beat us.”

The Panthers (10-10) did what no team has been able to do to the Cougars this season – keep them out of the cage and, of course, beat them.

The Cougars (18-1-1) had scored 117 goals in their first 19 games and had outscored their last five opponents 43-1. They were held to fewer than three goals only three times all year and never fewer than two. None of their top goal scorers – Ava Scurry (40 goals), Phoebe Alward (29) or Luci Virga (22) – lit the lamp Wednesday.

“We were aware of their scorers,” Panthers coach Valerie Dayton said. “I’m going to be honest, we don’t get fancy. We don’t do or change up a whole lot because I find our kids are comfortable doing what they do best. We just kind of talk them through what they could expect and if they made some adjustments on their own, they played smart.

“We don’t have the greatest record. We don’t have a record like they do. But we play in an extremely tough conference, we schedule tough out of conference and we hope that it pays off down the road. I think they really experienced some of the best teams in South Jersey, so even though we didn’t always come out on the winning end, we learned some lessons and it paid off today.”

The Panthers came into Salem County twice this week and snagged playoff wins. They edged Woodstown on Monday 1-0. They are the lowest seeded team and their 10 losses the most of all remaining teams in in the any classification in South Jersey. They visit third-seeded West Deptford in the semifinals Monday. It’s their sixth straight trip to the semis.

“It was all from hard work all season,” Panthers senior Peyton Ryan said. 

Schalick actually had the lead. Lena Virga converted a pass from her sister Luci for the first goal of the game with 8:27 left in the second quarter. The Panthers tied it on Sophia Mazur’s goal 1:35 before halftime and it stayed 1-1 until the Panthers scored twice in the fourth quarter.

Hazel Howkins broke the tie with 13:39 left on a penalty shot after Ryan got knocked down in the circle. With a flick of the wrist, Howkins sent her shot just past Cougar keeper Lydia Gilligan’s outstretched left hand. It was only the second time the Cougars had trailed all season.

“At first I was really nervous but I usually know where to place it because I practice them a lot since I’m the designated stroker,” she said. “I usually go to the right and just hope for the best … and try and be strong and send it hard.” 

It was uncertain how much of the goal Howkins actually saw. She took a piece of sour candy in the left eye during some roughhousing with a teammate during the school day and said after the game things still looked a little hazy.

“It was a lot puffier earlier,” she said.

Collingswood continued to dominate the play and got some breathing room on Ryan’s power play goal with 3:28 left. It came off a third straight corner following the penalty.

“For us it’s hard to play a man down,” Cheesman said. “Because we do a lot of man-to-man marking, a man down is leaving somebody open. Any time the play is uneven it’s tough.”

The Cougars picked up their play in the final five minutes, but just couldn’t get one in the cage. 

“I’m sad for them, but if they played this game like they played the last five minutes I think things would have turned out a lot different,” Cheesman said. “They just had a hard time putting it together today.”

SHORE 11, SALEM 0: The top-seeded Blue Devils (22-2) had their way with the Rams (9-6-1). Marielle Montenegro, Scarlett Watson, Marin Stefanelli and Gabby O’Brien all scored a pair of goals. Shore has outscored its first two tournament opponents 21-0.

Cover photo: Collingswood’s Hazel Howkins flicks a penalty shot past Schalick goalie Lydia Gilligan in the fourth quarter of their South Jersey Group I field hockey playoff game Wednesday. The shot broke a 1-1 tie.

Leave a comment